Mini COOPER S — Years to Avoid
Which model years have the most problems and which are safe to buy.
Avoid These Years
2010 Mini COOPER S
78 complaints (459% of segment average)
Main issue: COLD START PROBLEM, NO POWER, LOTS OF NOISE. TIMING CHAIN ON R56 MINI COOPER. THERE IS A SERVICE BULLETIN BUT THERE SHOULD BE A RECALL. IT SOUNDED LIKE THE MOTOR WAS GOING TO BLOW UP! *LN
2011 Mini COOPER S
46 complaints (271% of segment average)
Main issue: PREMATURE HIGH PRESSURE FUEL PUMP FAILURE MAY LEAD TO LOSS IN POWER, FURTHERING THE POTENTIAL FOR A WRECK. ENGINE ENTERS "LIMP HOME" MODE, WHICH REDUCES POWER CONSIDERABLY AND MAKES ACCELERATION MUCH SLOWER THAN NORMAL. CHECK ENGINE LIGHT COMES ON, SEVERAL OBD-II DIAGNOSTICS CODES APPEAR. *TR
2013 Mini COOPER S
32 complaints (188% of segment average)
Main issue: AIRBAG LIGHT IS SHOWING THAT PASSENGER AIRBAG IS OFF EVEN THOUGH MY 100 LBS DAUGHTER IS SITTING IN THE FRONT SEAT. I'VE ACTUALLY HAD A 2009 MINI COOPER S, 2011 MINI COOPER S AND NOW MY CURRENT 2013 MINI JOHN COOPER WORKS WITH THE SAME EXACT TAIL LIGHT ISSUE. THE DRIVER SIDE TAIL LIGHT BURNT OUT IN T
Safe to Buy
2025 Mini COOPER S
6 complaints — well below segment average
2019 Mini COOPER S
7 complaints — well below segment average
2020 Mini COOPER S
8 complaints — well below segment average
2017 Mini COOPER S
8 complaints — well below segment average
2016 Mini COOPER S
10 complaints — well below segment average
2014 Mini COOPER S
17 complaints — well below segment average